Research shows that educational gaps between children from different socioeconomic backgrounds begin to emerge in the earliest years of life, sometimes even before they enter educational frameworks. The first 1,000 days of life, from the beginning of pregnancy to age two, are considered a particularly sensitive period in child development. A previous study by Taub Center researchers found that family income during this period is more strongly associated with students’ academic achievements in fifth grade than family income during most later periods of childhood.
This study by the Taub Center Initiative on Early Childhood Development and Inequality, whose activities are generously supported by the Beracha Foundation, the Van Leer Foundation, and Yad Hanadiv, broadens the scope of the research by examining how changes in family income throughout childhood are associated with academic achievement in fifth grade. Researchers Dana Shay, Prof. Yossi Shavit, and Prof. Isaac Sasson examine whether improvements in a family’s economic circumstances after the first 1,000 days of life are associated with a narrowing of achievement gaps. Specifically, they investigate whether children who grew up in low-income families until age two, but whose families’ economic circumstances subsequently improved, achieve better academic outcomes than children who grew up in low-income families throughout childhood, and perhaps even outcomes similar to those of children who grew up in high-income families throughout childhood.
The study is based on data from Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics on children born in Israel between 2000 and 2005. The data indicate an association between parental income during the first 1,000 days of children’s lives and their achievements on the Meitzav exams in fifth grade. To examine changes in families’ economic circumstances, the researchers focused on three age periods: the first 1,000 days, ages 2–5, and ages 6–11. In each period, families were divided into two groups based on their income from employment: those with income above the median and those with income below the median.
Key findings
- The study found that for nearly four out of five children, their family’s relative income position remained stable throughout childhood: 42% of children grew up in families whose income was above the median in all three age periods examined, while 37% grew up in families whose income was below the median throughout all three periods. Among the remaining 21%, the family’s relative income position changed during childhood, whether through a move from the lower half of the income distribution to the upper half, a move in the opposite direction, or fluctuations between the two groups.
- Children who grew up in families whose income remained above the median throughout childhood had the highest average scores in mathematics, science, English (as a second language), and language arts (Hebrew). In contrast, children who grew up in families whose income was below the median in all three periods had the lowest average scores in these subjects.
- Children whose family income was below the median during their first 1,000 days of life but rose above the median later in childhood achieved higher average scores in all four subjects than children whose families remained below the median throughout childhood. This finding held both for children whose family income rose above the median at ages 2–5 and for those whose family income did not rise above the median until ages 6–11. However, even after their families’ relative economic circumstances improved, these children’s achievements in mathematics, English, and language arts (Hebrew) remained lower than those of children whose families were above the median throughout childhood. In science, by contrast, the achievements of children whose families moved above the median did not differ significantly from those of children whose families were above the median throughout childhood.
- The academic achievements of children whose families experienced a temporary decline in their economic circumstances—with family income above the median during the first 1,000 days, falling below the median at ages 2–5, and rising above it again at ages 6–11—did not differ significantly from those of children whose family income remained above the median throughout childhood. This finding may point to the importance of a secure economic position during the first 1,000 days of life, even when a family experiences a temporary decline in income later on. By contrast, when the decline below the median persisted through ages 6–11, children’s achievements in mathematics, English, and language arts were significantly lower than those of children whose families remained above the median throughout childhood, although they were higher than those of children whose families were below the median throughout childhood.
- The association between family income during the first 1,000 days of life and academic achievement was particularly pronounced in language arts and English. This may indicate the importance of economic circumstances during the earliest years of life for the development of children’s language skills.
The study’s findings support policies that work in two complementary directions
Taken together, the findings underscore the importance of family income during the earliest years of life. However, economic circumstances early in life do not necessarily determine academic achievement later on. This highlights the importance of supporting families from the very beginning of children’s lives, while also helping them improve and stabilize their economic circumstances as their children grow older. Such support may help narrow gaps in academic achievement and promote equal opportunities for children from different socioeconomic backgrounds.